Join GayCities, the fun way to discover the world
See where your friends and people like you are going and what they say about places and events worldwide.

Since 1937
This authentic family joint won't leave you disappointed with homemade ice cream and Italian foods.

Tags: Ice Cream, Italian

Added by: wayneb27 wayneb27

780 W Market St
Akron, OH 44303

(330) 253-1511

  • Mon-Thu 11:30am-10:00pm
  • Fri-Sat 11:30am-11:30pm
  • Sun 3:00pm-10:00pm


Join GayCities and share your take

  • January 9, 2016

  • October 29, 2015

  •   Old School
    jdhummell ·

    December 31, 2011

    Mary Coyle is truly an old school establishment. Everything about it screams 70+ years old. My partner and I came here around 8pm on a Saturday night. While he enjoyed the vibe more than I did, the ice cream sundae we split was alright. Service was good. The crowd consisted of mostly families, plus a group of high school kids. We were the only gay couple there and although we felt a little out of place after so many weekends in Columbus, no one really made us feel uncomfortable. After the ice cream, we went to see a movie at the Highland Theater, another bizarre place. I'm still not sure what to make of Highland Square.
  •   Homemade ice cream and Italian specialties
    wayneb27 ·

    October 18, 2011

    This place is a step back in time. This place has not changed in 75 years and is clean as a button. The ice cream is smooth and flavorful and the italian dishes are hand made by the owner. It is like being in a diner from the fifties.
    first review First to Review
  • wayneb27 is now a fan

    May 10, 2011


Aladdin's Eatery 4
782 West Market Street

Angel Falls Coffee Company 3.5
792 W Market St

Capri Pizza 4
810 W Market St

Mr. Zubs 4
812 W Market St

Wally Waffle 5
845 W. Market St.